Buttery Maple Syrup

  4.5 – 17 reviews  • Syrup Recipes

There are roughly 10 pancakes in this excellent handmade batter. Even though he is difficult to please, my recipe is a hit with him!

Prep Time: 5 mins
Cook Time: 5 mins
Total Time: 10 mins
Servings: 8
Yield: 8 servings

Ingredients

  1. 1 cup brown sugar
  2. ¾ cup water
  3. ½ cup white sugar
  4. 1 tablespoon butter
  5. 1 teaspoon maple-flavored extract

Instructions

  1. Heat brown sugar, water, white sugar, butter, and maple extract in a saucepan over medium-high heat; boil until thickened, about 3 minutes.

Reviews

Alan Boyd
its good
Amanda Lopez
I add almond and lemon flavor instead of maple.
Alyssa Rodriguez
Good little on the thin side. I’m going to add some brown sugar to what I have left over.?
Jill Rivera
I added butter flavoring and a little extra butter making it so no butter needed to be added to pancakes. I love the fact you do not need corn syrup. My family of five loved it!!! This is my “go to” syrup recipe!!!
Alan Russell
Best ever!
Mrs. Jessica Wood
Being diabetic I normally play around with ingredients. This one I substituted stevia for the white sugar and added an extra teaspoon of maple.
Lauren Carter
Super easy and super good. Tastes just like bottled syrup but brighter and fresher. I only made a little at a time becuase it does start to crystallize after a few days in the fridge.
Richard Walters
Best syrup I have ever had. 2 tbsp butter. Boiled to 223-230 C to thicken. Next morning after refrigeration it was perfectly thick and rich and delicious!
Gabriel Vazquez
Easy and tasty! I like that it doesn’t have high fructose corn syrup. I didn’t have maple extract, so used pure vanilla extract and it was great.
Jose Stanley
I have yet to go out and buy maple extract, so I just use pure vanilla and it’s delicious. I’ve found that adding more butter makes this even tastier with no more effort. I looked for this recipe when we were out of maple syrup and have been alternating between maple syrup and this gem ever since.
Mrs. Kathryn Schaefer
Will make time and time again! Loved it. Tastes like my mom’s.
Chelsea Roberts
I like this recipe because it’s very easy and I didn’t have corn syrup for one of the other recipes that I reviewed. I’m wondering why I would need it at all. My syrup came out nice and thick although the butter made it a little less clear. I use raw sugar with the light brown sugar and I also used the same amount of vanilla and it is delicious. I saved my old bottle and I used for this recipe a vinegar bottle and it made about 2 cups. Thank you
Jennifer Boone
This worked out nicely – I added a tsp of vanilla. Family ate it up!
Dana Ryan
I was very disappointed in this recipe. It just didn’t come out at all. I am not a novice cook and have made syrups before but this was just not good. Very grainy I am not sure I will try it again, if I do I will update review. But at this point not so much.
Cynthia Fischer
Super easy and the kids loved it! And, even though it isn’t good for them, I feel much better giving my kids this syrup vs the syrup with high fructose corn syrup as the main ingredient! I also made a version with rum extract and vanilla extract!
Lisa Smith
Great, easy, fast syrup!
David Schultz
I prefer only real maple syrup, but miss the thickness of the fake syrups. I recommend using light brown sugar vs dark. After completely cooled & a taste test I increased the maple extract to nearly another tsp. I buy the maple extract from Kroger.

 

Leave a Comment