Peanut Butter Haystacks

  4.7 – 263 reviews  

Dill, lemon, and bacon lend a unique spin to the classic egg salad.

Prep Time: 15 mins
Cook Time: 5 mins
Total Time: 20 mins
Servings: 12
Yield: 24 haystacks

Ingredients

  1. waxed paper
  2. 1 cup butterscotch chips
  3. ½ cup peanut butter
  4. 2 cups chow mein noodles
  5. ½ cup salted peanuts

Instructions

  1. Line a baking tray with waxed paper.
  2. Allrecipes/Madhumita Sathishkumar
  3. Place butterscotch chips and peanut butter in the top of a double boiler over simmering water. Stir frequently, scraping down the sides with a rubber spatula to avoid scorching, until melted, about 5 minutes.
  4. Allrecipes/Madhumita Sathishkumar
  5. Stir noodles and peanuts into melted peanut butter mixture.
  6. Allrecipes/Madhumita Sathishkumar
  7. Drop dough by forkfuls onto the prepared tray. Allow to cool at room temperature until set.
  8. Allrecipes/Madhumita Sathishkumar
  9. You may use a microwave if you don’t have a double boiler.

Reviews

Melissa Green
Without the peanuts though because I don’t like them.
Philip Adams
I made a couple of changes, dark chocolate chips and chunky peanut butter, and Fiber One cereal. Delicious! And i used mini muffin papers and filled them! Clean!
Andrew Flores
Love love love these. Stores ran out of chow mien noodles so I used the thin pretzel sticks. Worked well!
Ariel Mercado
So good! So easy to make!! They are always a big hit when I take them to parties, folks asking for more!
Tracy Harris PhD
I loved making Haystacks.A good first try snack. Tasty and fun to make with Family.
Megan Maddox
I cut the peanuts and add cashews .. my grandmother made them that way and we love them ❤️
Jennifer Hunt
I brought these to a Christmas party and they were gone in 60 seconds.
Scott Johnson
Add mini marshmallows, and when putting on the wax paper arrange each stack more flat with a few of the noodles splayed out to look like bagpipes and you’ve got the recipe for Nancy Drew’s Whistling Bagpipe Crunchies from the Nancy Drew cookbook. Ah, good memories from attempting those crazy old recipes. A tip if you ever find that book, never ever try the peanut butter soup. It was horrible, and I tried to make it twice thinking I messed it up, nope just a terrible recipe.
Amy Church
I’ve been making these for years and everyone loves them!
Miss Sarah Wheeler
My next door neighbor made these when I was growing up. She told me the ingredients but I didn’t remember the proportions. Thanks for this great recipe so that I could recreate a memory from my youth!!
Johnathan Murray
They ended up sticky.
Suzanne Moore
My family has made these for Christmas for decades! Our recipe includes multi-colored mini-marshmallows (mix in quickly so they don’t melt). Stack these up high to look like a decorated Christmas Tree. The marshmallows are a delicious and colorful addition.
Pamela Thomas
Quick, easy, and delicious. Thanks!
Lisa Benjamin
I have made these several times..always a hit! I have substituted the peanut butter with semi sweet chocolate chips and cashews for the peanuts. For making nests for Easter I have subbed the chow mein noodles with corn flakes.
Matthew Meadows
These are tasty and quick! I remember them being called ‘Hopscotch’ back in the 60’s. I make a switched up version of these using peanut butter, vanilla bark, dry roast salted peanuts, crispy rice cereal and miniature marshmallows. They’re a huge hit as well.
Tammy Colon
This was a fantastic recipe. They turned out great. I didn’t have a double boiler so I used my dutch oven on the lowest setting on the stove top. I continually stirred. I don’t think they took very long to set up. Once I placed on wax paper, I just left on countertop maybe an hour or so. I want to try adding chocolate next time.
Michael Ward
GREAT SWITCHED OUT THE PEANUT BUTTER FOR CASHEW BUTTER AND ADDED A HANDFUL OF COCONUT FLAKES.
Caitlyn Orr
No one from my family would eat these, so I guess that speaks volumes : (
Edward Peters
I omitted peanuts and added marshmallows to half(for the kids) set up perfect!
Carolyn Bowen
I added 1 1/2 cups mini marshmallows and melted them with peanut butter and chips I also use chunky peanut butter instead of creamy and skip the peanuts. Delicious !
Michael Hamilton
Great, easy recipe and I will definitely make it again! I did add a few more peanuts to my recipe.

 

Leave a Comment