Pink Lemonade Pie

I was sceptical of this recipe. In the past the recipe I used called for a small box of lemon jello. I now know why. Its what keeps the pie together. This recipe taste the same as the old one but it was very runny. I think I will continue adding the lemon jello mix.

This is so easy! A real treat on a hot day. I have used limeade, orange juice, and lemonade to change it up. If I make my own graham cracker crust, I put it in cupcake liners in a muffin tin. In the freezer I have kept them 3-4 weeks in a Tupperware freezer container, but don’t know if they would last longer . . . they get consumed pretty quickly!!

I followed the recipe, and kept the pie in the freezer, but it melted too quickly. I made it again with 4 oz of cream cheese, but it was still melty. I will try it again with 8 oz of cream cheese, which, btw is the Eagle Brand recipe. I’m going to keep trying because the flavor is great.

Loved the cool taste for summer

If your pie is runny it’s because you mixed the whipped topping in instead of folding. You have to fold it carefully with out popping the air bubbles in the whipped cream.

simply easy simply amazing love the recipe

This takes me back to the summers I spent with my Mam-Maw. Thank you!

Love this recipe. So simple and delicious. I did substitute 1 pack Pink Lemonade Kool-Aid mix in place of the frozen pink lemonade and I only had to refrigerate it about an hour. It stayed together nicely and tasted great. Will be making many more times !

This is a great no bake recipe, especially for a hot summer day when you don’t want to turn the oven on. You definitely have to freeze this for it to set. Everyone loved it and there were no leftovers. Definitely recommended.

I originally found this recipe through my Grams, and it’s not entirely correct. You should honestly freeze it or it will be runny. If you want a more cheesecake-feel, add creamcheese and sugar in lieu of condensed milk. I’ve been making this since well before 2000 and not once have I ever had a runny pie, let alone a single complaint. It’s versatile as well. You can use whatever juice is available and trust me, it’s gonna be good.

My mom always made this pie. Make sure you look at the size of the pink lemonade, minutemaid is 12 oz. My pie was a little runny because of this. I found the recipe only made on pie as others have said. A couple of drops of red food coloring gives it a pretty pink color. Yummy!

I found it helpful to bake it for 8-10 minutes. Helps with the firmness of filling and crust

Easy. Delicious. Nuff said right? It’s fairly runny following the directions. We kept both in the freezer and snacked on them all week. Pretty tart and sweet, which we found delicious.

This is such an easy and versatile pie. I make as directed except I chill the can of milk in the refrigerator and whip the chilled milk and the Cool-whip together first until thick, then I gently fold in the lemonade concentrate until blended. When I do this, the pie sets really well in just a few hours in the freezer. I make my own graham cracker crust and pre-bake in the oven (I do this the day before). I take out about 15 minutes before serving so I can slice through the filling (how long you let sit out depends on how hot it is in the house). I use the pink lemonade concentrate and unless you add some red food coloring it’s not pink at all, more like a light blush.

Found this same Recipe on another Recipe site. They recommended using the Frozen Lemonade, still frozen and chilling the sweetened condensed milk before mixing anything. They then have you gently fold the sweetened condensed milk into the thawed whipped topping , and then gently folding in the Frozen Lemonade to avoid the mixture from getting too liquid-y. They then poured filling into the Graham Cracker Crust and froze it over night so it would set! I tried this, and it set up fine, even in our current very hot weather!

easy peasy lemon squeezy. such a great recipe, takes five minutes to make, waiting till it chills is very tough :). didn’t change a thing and it is so delicious. will make all summer!!

I make this pie ALL the time and I only use HALF a can of the Pink lemonade concentrate and that helps the pie to be a little firmer and sweeter. Also, I always try to make it 24hours in advance (yum)!

I loved the creativity of this pie, but when I made it (EXACTLY as the recipe instructed), my fiance and I both agreed that the end result was too sour. Maybe we used the wrong brand lemonade concentrate or something, but it was really really sour. I had garnished our pie with pink-colored sweetened coconut shavings, so at least I can say the pie was pretty 🙂

I make this with both the pink lemonade and the limeade and my family loves it so much that my brother-in-law dubbed it “FamilyPie.”

My sister-in-law makes these for our get togethers and they are so good.

I have been making this pie for 30 years. It’s so super easy and kids love it! Great icebox pie for the 100 degree plus temps in West Texas!