Easter Story Cookies

  4.5 – 29 reviews  

The caramelization that occurs during roasting gives cabbage a sweet, nutty flavor that other preparation techniques can not produce. The ideal complement to corned beef or pot roast is fragrant caraway seeds combined with melted butter.

Servings: 24
Yield: 1 1/2 to 2 1/2 dozen

Ingredients

  1. 1 cup pecan halves
  2. 1 teaspoon distilled white vinegar
  3. 3 egg whites
  4. 1 pinch salt
  5. 1 cup white sugar

Instructions

  1. Preheat oven to 300 degrees F (150 degrees C).
  2. Place pecans in a resealable plastic baggie. Crush the pecans into small bits. Read John 19:1-3
  3. Put 1 teaspoon vinegar into a medium bowl. Read John 19:28-30
  4. Add egg whites to the vinegar. Read John 10:10-11
  5. Sprinkle salt into the egg whites. Read Luke 23:27
  6. So far, the mixture isn’t very appetizing. Add 1cup sugar. Read Psalm 34:8 and John 3:16. Beat with mixer on high speed for 12 to 15 minutes until stiff peaks are formed. Read Isaiah 1:18 and John 3:1-3.
  7. Fold in broken nuts. Drop by teaspoons onto parchment paper lined baking sheet. Read Matthew 27:57-60.
  8. Place cookies in the oven close the door and turn the oven off. Read Matthew 27:65-66.
  9. Go to bed. Read John 16:20 and 22.
  10. In the morning open the oven and take out the cookies. Read Matthew 28:1-9.

Reviews

Christian Gaines
This is a great recipe! It got the kids involved when not much else would. The final product was great too! We added vanilla in the sugar step, but other than that did everything exactly as directed. They are light, fluffy, and sweet. The pecans make it really good, but you could even sub chocolate chips or another nut.
Jermaine Pearson
Followed recipe exactly as written. Came out great.
Justin Wright
I would definitely make these again. I just used the recipe for the ingredients. I added some vanilla and baked at 225 for 1 hour and then left in the closed oven turned off for another 1.5 hours. They turned out perfect. I also added crushed up mini eggs.
Jason Higgins
awesome! its wonderful way to teach about Jesus! love it
Breanna Carlson
As others have noted, the cookies are just OK. They are very sweet but don’t have much flavor besides that and the pecans. My family still enjoyed them, and they thought the lightness was interesting. However, the point of this recipe isn’t the finished product; it’s the message that goes along with it. Because of that, I gave a higher rating than I would normally give for the recipe itself.
Annette Neal
These were simple to make and my 3 and 4 year old loved the experience and the taste the next day. Since my kids are a bit young it worked better to tell them the basics about the ingredients then during the 17 minutes of mixing read the passages and let them taste test the ingredients again to solidify the meaning. My 3 year old was able to tell me what each ingredient meant as we sealed the tomb. Also, the parchment paper can be like the burial cloths and when we searched for the cookies the next day I left the cookie sheets with the used paper in the oven and placed the cookies in a decorated basket to solidify that Jesus was alive, not in the tomb and had a perfected body. Thank you so much-this is our new Easter tradition. HE IS RISEN!!!
Peter Atkinson
do you have to have the almands
Jason Molina
I have been looking for this recipe for a long time! I’m so glad you have it on here. My mother used to make this recipe with me when I was young, but somehow the recipe got lost and she couldn’t remember it. She and I would also tape the oven door shut to “seal the tomb”.
John Martinez
These cookies have been an Easter Eve tradition for years now. Great recipe! And the Message behind it (along with the verses) is an excellent teaching opportunity for the true meaning of Easter. I do make one very important modification. My family hates nuts. I use MINI chocolate chips (and still beat them in the bag). My hubby can’t get enough of these cookies! They are sweet but yummy!
Cody Miranda
I originally received this recipe from a very dear friend of my mother’s, but her version was called Overnight Oven Cookies I believe. As I lost that recipe, I ended up here. Can’t speak to the religious nature of the cookies, but I can say that for someone forced into a gluten free diet these cookies are fab. It takes time (and many failures) to get the alternative flour thing down, so this recipe offers a particularly good alternative to horrifically expensive GF store-bought cookies (providing patience (or a bad memory) is a virtue you possess).
William Wolf
very bland
Michelle Blackburn
I am giving 5 stars not for the tasty (I don’t really like them- too sweet), but for the story and experience that goes with them. A good family tradition!
Brooke Fernandez
Amazing cookies!! We now have a new Easter eve tradition! I made the following changes: almonds instead of pecans and add 1 tsp of vanilla for extra flavor. We made these the night before Easter and then brought some to Easter dinner with the rest of the family. They were a BIG hit! My son loved making them and retelling the Easter story to the family at Easter dinner. Everyone kept asking where I found the recipe, how we made these and how we got them to be hollow. We will be making these again!
Phillip Chapman
What a neat way to teach kids about Jesus! I followed the recipe except added 1/2 teaspoon of almond extract. I used a kitchen aid mixer and whipped on high for 10 minutes, then another 2 minutes and finally another 2 minutes. I got about 28 small to medium sized beautifully white and delicate cookies! I used crushed walnuts in only half the batter. I think they tastes rather good and ate 3 myself.
Todd Mcdaniel
This was a very nice activity for our whole family. The cookies didn’t taste all that great (I think I’ll reduce the pecans by half next time), but it didn’t matter. The beauty is in the symbolism. Thank you so much for posting this recipe. It was a wonderful way to remind ourselves, and our children, what Easter is really about.
Kimberly Thompson
I think these were very good for what they are. I was much more interested in the scriptural lesson for the kids than I was in the end product. My husband gave them a 3 but ate almost the whole batch and proclaimed them addictive. I added a teaspoon of vanilla during the sugar step, without which these cookies would have been very bland. Not bad, mind you, just bland. Thanks for sharing this recipe.
Anne Jones
This has become an Easter tradition at my house. My whole family gets involved and we each take a part. It makes my mother in law cry every time. Such a wonderful way to experience the Easter Story!
Crystal Moore
Fun! East=y! Kid Friendly! Thanks!
Jason Hall
I was so excited to see this recipe that I have made copies for my children and friends to do with there children. And I know that the women at church will want this recipe. This is such a BLESSING. GOD BLESS YOU FOR IT….
Karen Cox
Per another review, I added 1 1/2 tsp of vanilla. These are pretty good, considering the few ingrediants. However, we really enjoyed the idea of these cookies and it was a nice project to do with my daughter the night before Easter. I would do this again next year.
Kirsten Green
Per another review, I added 1 1/2 tsp of vanilla. These are pretty good, considering the few ingrediants. However, we really enjoyed the idea of these cookies and it was a nice project to do with my daughter the night before Easter. I would do this again next year.

 

Leave a Comment