New York Strip Chicago Style

  3.9 – 48 reviews  • Strip Steak Recipes

These cheese-filled handmade tortillas are a delicacy from El Salvador and go well with curtido, the country’s version of coleslaw. Cut a pupusa open on one side and place a spoonful of curtido inside. In place of queso blanco, mozzarella or farmer’s cheese can be used.

Prep Time: 15 mins
Cook Time: 10 mins
Additional Time: 1 hr
Total Time: 1 hr 25 mins
Servings: 2
Yield: 2 servings

Ingredients

  1. 1 tablespoon extra virgin olive oil
  2. 1 clove garlic, minced
  3. ½ teaspoon ground cinnamon
  4. ½ teaspoon white sugar
  5. 2 tablespoons apricot preserves
  6. 2 (1/2 pound) New York strip steaks, 1 inch thick
  7. salt and pepper to taste

Instructions

  1. In a shallow glass dish, mix the olive oil, garlic, cinnamon, sugar, and apricot preserves. Mix well, as the preserves tend to stick until warm.
  2. With a knife, make several shallow slashes in both sides of the steaks. Sprinkle with salt and pepper. Place steaks in the dish with the sauce, and turn to coat. Cover with plastic wrap, and refrigerate for at least 1 hour.
  3. Preheat grill for high heat.
  4. Lightly oil the grill grate. Place steaks on the grill, and discard any remaining sauce. Grill steaks 10 minutes, turning occasionally, or to desired doneness.

Nutrition Facts

Calories 439 kcal
Carbohydrate 15 g
Cholesterol 134 mg
Dietary Fiber 0 g
Protein 49 g
Saturated Fat 6 g
Sodium 142 mg
Sugars 10 g
Fat 19 g
Unsaturated Fat 0 g

Reviews

Elizabeth Odonnell
Marinade made the meat watery. Did another steak without marinade which was fine. Would not do it again.
Kenneth Garcia
I loved this recipe. I had no apricot preserves, so I used hot mango chutney and some teriyaki. Marinated overnight. The meats grilled beautifully and my family loved the flavor. Thank you!
Brandon Mccall
Absolutely delicious. I did not have Apricot Jam on hand so I used Peach Jam and would definitely use Peach Jam again. I do love Apricot Jam and will also try that another time.
Herbert Rice
I really liked the marinade but for me the sweetness didn’t pair well with beef. I think it would be really good with something like pork or chicken, which I’ll try next.
Bobby Wallace
The taste was really good, though a bit on the sweet side. Since there would be 4 of us, I doubled the recipe. I don’t know if the original recipe for 2 turned out differently, but the doubled one did not make enough marinade for 4 New York strips. I would make this again though I would make extra marinade.
Michelle Rocha
OK EASY. Steak was alright tonight. It’s a matter of preference. It’s BBQ season andI like to have different things. So I try this. For us , the flavors of cinnamon and preserves, does not go with a steak. Meal was fine, good to experiment, but this isn’t our steak flavour.
Rebecca Johnson
I was very pleasantly surprised by this recipe! I initially wasn’t sure how I would feel about the cinnamon and preserves, but the marinade paired very well with the steak. I made this per the recipe, though grilled on high direct heat initially for a sear and then lowered the temp to a medium indirect heat for approximately 6 mins per side (ended up medium well).
Joel Wilkinson
This was delicious! Tender meat with a slight sweet/cinnamon flavor. However I would consider add a little heat to the marinate for a sweet and spicy taste. I marinated all day in the fridge and turned out great.
Travis Douglas
Easy to make, added lots of flavor to steak. Good marinade recipes
Heidi Davis
Made this one twice and will keep doing it. It just seems to be missing something but I will keep trying. Really nice steak..
Laura Prince
No changes were made and will make it again.
John Chaney
yes, I would make this again !
Molly Clark
I tried this with some short ribs and it was horrible. Never again people. Sweet meat nasty
Ryan Rodriguez
Quite nice. I thought it was an interesting twist on a favourite meal of mine.
Tina Shaffer
I did this recipe using a 1/2 lb sirloin grilling steak.. Man it was delicious with a hint of apricot flavour. Definitely a keeper!
Kimberly Henry
I have not made this recipe, but I have eaten in all the major Chicago steakhouses. They all serve their best steaks nekkid. S&P only.
Nicholas Carson
Yikes! I am from Chicago and have dined in some of the finest steak restaurants in the city. Absolutely NOTHING like this was ever served.
Robert Hall
There are lots of variations on this but they’re basically almost the same. I personally don’t like garlic in mine, I prefer it sweeter. We use shallots and red wine and a seedless blackberry preserve. It adds so much to red meat.
George Wilson
I thought that the flavor would be unique but it just didn’t do the cut of steak justice. There are plenty of great tasting marinades on the A.R. website to like,this isn’t one of them.
Steven Johnson
I left out the sugar as there’s enough sweetness between the apricot preserve and cinnamon. This was a different style of barbecue sauce season.
Christopher Sellers
It tasted as I expected, but fail to see why it was called Chicago style…..never had it that way in any restaurant in Chicago……

 

Leave a Comment