Baked Green Tomatoes

  3.2 – 37 reviews  

The first person to admit that I’m not a baker is me. Having said that, every now and then I’ll try to make a pie. I bought pre-made, chilled pie crusts for this pie, along with frozen peach slices. When I served my family a piece of this pie with vanilla ice cream on top, they had no questions for me. The only thing they said was, “Wow!”

Prep Time: 15 mins
Cook Time: 45 mins
Total Time: 1 hr
Servings: 6

Ingredients

  1. 1 cup cornmeal
  2. 1 tablespoon dried dill weed
  3. salt to taste
  4. ground black pepper to taste
  5. 5 medium green tomatoes, thinly sliced

Instructions

  1. Preheat the oven to 325 degrees F (165 degrees C). Lightly grease a medium baking sheet.
  2. Mix cornmeal, dill, salt, and pepper in a small bowl. Dip tomato slices into mixture, coating both sides. Arrange coated slices in a single layer on a medium baking sheet.
  3. Bake in the preheated oven until crisp and golden brown, about 45 minutes.

Reviews

Julia Morales
I love green tomatoes and this is a healthy recipe but just a little bland
Christopher Walker
I use a cooling rack and turn them halfway through baking. I also use a little Italian breadcrumbs and some panko and never a problem with them crisping.
Tommy Stuart
A tasty way of using tomatoes at the end of the season.
Ryan Dunn
The addition of dill was a nice change. Baking takes longer but it’s worth it. Next time I will turn them same as if they were fried so they’ll be crisp on both sides.
Tamara Myers
Very disappointed in flavor and texture. Did not seem like fried green tomatoes at all. Guess cooking in the grease is the only way…
Vicki Douglas
These were excellent! The taste of fried green tomatoes without the grease and the problem of all the breading falling off! I jist added so e garlic powder to the breading to suit our taste but it was excellent!
Zachary Campbell
Nope, not nearly as good as fried. I guess if you were really craving them and couldn’t have the real deal, then that would be okay. They just don’t crisp up like I wanted and they were a bit chewy.
Christopher Perez
Bland, and for me, using corn mean overpowers the tomato, does not complement it at all. I will try again, using other reviewers suggestions of mixing in Italian bread crumbs and maybe some ranch dressing powder (don’t add salt if you use ranch dressing powder though, as it is very salty already). Nutritional yeast would also add a nice flavor component to the mix. I would also recommend dredging the slices in egg to make the coating stick and to add some crunch. And probably would work better to bake at higher temp for shorter time period.
Steven Gomez
Thought this would be a great alternative to fried green tomatoes, but didn’t care for these and couldn’t finish them. I wish it would have worked because I like the idea of lower calories.
Carolyn White
I found these to be too dry. I saw a previous comment that said hers were too greasy, but I didn’t get that since there is no oil or grease in the recipe. Perhaps it depends on the tmayders (tomatoes).
Heather York
I had high hopes for this recipe and thought it would be a good alternative to frying the tomatoes. I added my usual favorite spices to give it a kick, and threw them in the oven. There was nothing to make the coating adhere and crispy – it was like dumping cornmeal on a cooked tomato. Perhaps mixing a small amount of oil in the mixture of cornmeal and spices might help with the texture. I’ll give that a try next time.
Timothy Gilbert
Much better than fried! Crispy, not greasy. I cut my tomatoes about 1/4 inch but will make them a bit thicker next time. I let the slices rest for awhile, then shook them in a bag with the corn meal (+ seasoned bread crumbs), and flipped them 1/2 way through baking. They were crisp on the outside and perfectly done on the inside. We’ll make these again before all the green tomatoes are gone.
Jose Johnson
I did not care for this.
Jenny Medina
This was good but did lack in seasoning, so I will add a little garlic or onion powder next time, but overall good for a baked tomato, thanks for sharing.
Thomas Watson
Yum! I didn’t slice most of my tomatoes thin enough so the majority didn’t get crispy, but thye were still tasty. They need to be pretty thin, like less than 1/4″, to get them really nice and crisp. I served them with the dill sauce from Hudson’s Baked Tilapia with Dill Sauce from this site. Thanks!! 🙂
Steven Gray
this is good and even better with a few changes–spray the slices with olive oil spam and then dredge in the cornmeal–i did this by first laying all of the slices in the baking sheet–spraying them all-flipping them all-spaying other side and then dipping and cooking–add what ever spices you want –i added a smokey spice–i like the slices pretty thin
Catherine Sullivan
Neither my husband nor myself cared for this. It was too sour and tasteless.
Ronald Cummings
The concept of this recipe is GREAT- Yes, you need to season it more but if you follow the process-slice thin, flour, egg wash, cornmeal/breadcrumbs you get a great alternative to fried green tomatoes. And they reheat wonderfully!
Mark Miller
I would only give this recipe four stars based on the changes I made to it, otherwise, it seems too bland, and I personally don’t like a lot of dill. This recipe is definitely health-conscious, and the changes I made are not…but it’s still not fried which must count for something! Instead of cornmeal, I used panko to which I added melted butter, a pinch of ground cayenne pepper and used another reviewer’s suggestion of grated parmesan cheese. I dipped the salted/peppered tomato slices in an egg wash before covering with the panko mixture. I baked according to the instructions but placed the tomatoes on top of a wire cooling rack inside of a foil-covered cookie sheet. This allowed the bottoms to become somewhat crisp without having to turn over. I made these for a party and they were a big hit. Everyone wanted to know how I did it. I served them on a platter with a dipping sauce I made from a Hidden Valley Ranch mix and added a couple drops of Tobasco Chipotle Pepper Sauce for an extra kick. These are messy which I think is their only downfall, but very good. Serve them right out of the oven if you can!
Matthew Finley
No, it’s not quite as tasty as the fried variety but the health benefits make up for the difference. I did substitute garlic salt. I have made this several times and experimented with different seasonings. A good alternative fried.
Douglas Wilson
Unfortunately, they don’t compare to the fried version. The texture is off, but they taste good.

 

Leave a Comment