Coal Miners Pasties

The information at the first says savory on one end and sweet on the other. What happened to the sweet?

This was a great recipe and a new favorite! Actually I was trying to find a recipe for a “Cornish Pasty” after seeing this on the Andy Griffith show, where an English guest makes these “with afters” ( or “double-ended”) – meat and potatoes on one side and plum pudding on the other! We used this recipe and I used diced apples and pears with blueberry filling on the dessert side. I also added garlic on the savory side, and substituted butter for lard in the pastry. Make sure you put in a wall or shield of dough between the two sides, which I found suggested after some research on the English version. I ended up learning a lot about Cornish Pasties and Coal Minors Pasties! It seems the debut on the Andy Griffith Show made quite a stir in England among bakers!

This recipe sucked. The dough completely failed at being dough. I followed every step, did everything correctly, and then when I went to roll out the dough, it fell apart. It was impossible to fold the dough over the meat filling, so we kinda squished it around the meat, and there were tons of holes all over. Then we tried to eat it. It tasted horrible. The crust was so horrible and dry that I just took it off and tried to eat the meat, potatoes, ect. I ate less than half of one before giving it to the dog to try. She ate it, but I could tell she didnt really want to. My mom even got sick. I followed the recipe and did everything the way it said to. :/

Perfect…. great crust… freezes very well…. but browned my meat first

I used cream corn in mine to make it creamy. Delicious. I wrapped them almost fully in foil. I cooked it at 300 for an hour and a half. Then opened up to foil and cooked at 400 for 20 minutes to darken the crust. Steak was super tender.

I am very popular in my family for this recipe. Thank you. Now my bucket list is to go visit Cornwall & snack on a pasty

This looks very good. A real cornish pastie had the dessert on the back end of the pastry.

I’m from Northeastern PA..Coal country..we make these all the time for church fundraisers. Ground Beef, white potatoes, onions and served with Brown gravy. You can save tons of time at home by using pre-made pie crust. Layer Potatoes, meat then oniion seasoning with salt and pepper and some allspice as you go. NO NEED TO COOK ANYTHING BEFORE..bake hour or so in 375 oven…pour gravy over and enjoy!

Very good. Easy to make. I made it for my parents and my sister and they enjoyed it very much. I added just a hint of garlic powder and it was good. It smelled terrific and made mouths water as they came out of the oven.

The only thing I did different was to eat this meal with a bit of ketchup. Fabulous recipe. Thank you!

I’m rating my changes, not the original recipe. On paper recipe looked good, but found I didn’t have turnips so used what I had on hand. I used frozen onions and fried them down to take the twange out. In place of turnips, I used 3/4 a small bag of “stir-fry veggies w/rice” and white potatoes in place of red. Reds have a better flavor. In place of round steak, I used 5 veggie meatballs I froze last year (this was a big mistake, as it made the recipe taste unusual). The pasties are huge, bigger than I had stomach for. I used 2 cookie sheets (3 on each). When all was in oven, I thought baking at 400 degrees would burn the dough but it did not. Actually, I added 5 minutes to the 45-minute baking time to get a golden color. The pastry was a little bland for me (I got spoiled making sugar-crusted appled pie from this site), yet it was flaky and didn’t fall apart. Next time I make this recipe I’ll be sure to use turnips. I may add a little sugar (for taste) to the dough. Thanks for sharing your recipe, Kevin.

This is a great crust but the inside is pretty dry, I even made gravy from the steak that I browned and added it to the mixture and it was still to dry. Next time I will use a different meat and have gravy on the table as well and like someone else said, it has a lot of left over potatoes and turnip mixture, that is true, I guess you should use the tiny red potatoes and small turnips. This is a great recipe to try different fillings with. Oh yes and also, the next day the crust is still nice and flaky even after heating up in the microwave.

The meat was very good, but the crust was dry and crumbly. There were far too many potatoes and it was overall very bland. I think it could be better with a different crust and more seasoning. It was a good concept but I was not impressed.

Pasties has been a staple in my husband’s (Southern) family for decades. It has become our Christmas Eve dinner tradition for several years now. We don’t add the turnips but would not be opposed to it. We do however add “several” (the more the better) pats of butter with the meat etc. It makes it nice & juicy & makes the meat more tender. My husband is the pastie maker & it’s wonderful. We always serve Mrs. Renfrow’s Chow Chow with it.

my grandmother made these pasties back in the early 1920’s. they grew there own veggies and meat so she was not out much. i remember her telling me about her making these and selling them to men that were working on FDR’s reconstruction project here in alabama. i am so glad that you came up with is recipe because if have lost her original recipe she gave me. grandmother was the one who taught me to cook beginning when i was three and old enough to stand on a chair and stir ingredients in a bowl. i guess many of the older ladies can tell stories just like mine. i know when i was in high school and my sewing and cooking teacher was in awe because i already knew how to sew and cook. i hope you put more recipes from the 1920’s and 1930’s online so we can review and see if we can make them more healthy for todays lifestyle. mary king marob_532, ashville alabama

I used to live in SD and would get pasties at King’s Grocery across from the Homestake gold mine in Lead. This recipe is the closest I have ever made to their recipe. Wonderful! For breakfast try adding scrambled eggs, crumbled bacon and hash browns. I will be making these again and again.

This has always been a favorite. Although I make it with ground beef and it is never dry. I also didn’t use turnips, just ground beef, onion and chopped/sliced potatoes. Since I had a big family I made it often in a pie plate. After slices were cut some topped it with gravy, chili sauce or ketchup. I alsways liked my plain.

My family is from the anthracite coal region of Pennsylvania, and my grandmother would make them for us. She came from such a large family that they used hamburger instead of steak and my great-grandmother made them in the form of a pie rather that the traditional folded-over version. Regardless, they are WONDERFUL!

delicious filling. i added sautéed onion and garlic. Pastry was a disaster. Too flaky. barely held together and had a funny taste. I grew up on pie crust with butter or vegetable shortening and it is much easier to work with.i will try again.

These are excellent. I was born and raised in northern Wisconsin and my dad worked in northern Michigan for 10 years so we are very familiar with pasties. I make mine with ground chuck, carrots, onions, red potatoes, and rutabega. I also use the refrigerated Pillsbury pie crust (not the frozen Pet-Ritz kind) which makes them quick and easy to make and they still taste great. Now living in Texas with my Texas-born husband, he insists I add chili power and cumin to the filling. So nontraditional, but it’s still good!

Everyone in the family loved this recipe, which is VERY rare. I made the following changes: Parsnips instead of turnips (what I had on hand). Fresh ground garlic pepper instead of regular fresh ground pepper. No added salt in the filling; it was salty enough with just the salt from the pastry and the garlic pepper – I couldn’t imagine a whole extra tablespoon. I also chopped in some scallions and fresh parsley from the garden. I had quite a bit of extra filling and just baked that in a covered pan for leftovers. I agree with another reviewer that this makes a lot – only someone with a very hearty appetite could eat a whole one. Rave reviews all around the table!